Tabletop role playing games, or TTRPGs for short, have existed for over 50 years. The first one published was Dungeon and Dragons (D&D) in 1974. It was derived from the creators’ love of wargames, but they wanted a version where they played as the hero instead of the army. Over the years there have been 5 main editions released of D&D, with the latest being 5e in 2014 and its revised version 5.5e in 2024. During all these years it’s been through a lot of controversy, growth and love. What I will be focusing on in this text is the consequences of what was released with 3e, removed in 4e and brought back again with 5e, where the developers suggested changes to it that made the community respond with outrage and make a whole new version of it.
In 2000, D&D 3e was released by Wizards of the Coast (WotC), and with the release they included something that would impact the TTRPG scene in a big way – the Open Gaming License (OGL). The OGL 1.0 would benefit the community and third-party publishers and let them create their own version of TTRPGs via the System Reference Document (SDR), which contained the core features, rules and elements from D&D 3e. Monsters, spells and other elements were available as long as it was not connected to named places or people.
The OGL also included the D20 system, named after the 20-sided die. This system has inspired many other TTRPGs, including Pathfinder made by Paizo – more on them later.
Sadly, with the release of D&D 4e, the OGL was not included. Luckily the original OGL was still in use and under its own terms active in perpetuity. In 2016, the D&D 5e SDR was released under the OGL v.1.0a again. With this, content creators got access to a deal that would allow them to use the intellectual property of WotC and sell it through OneBookShelf, Inc, now known as Wolves of Freeport, for whatever price they wanted, and keep 50% of the profit.
Now the reason I’m specifying the Open Gaming License 1.0a is that in 2022 WotC had an open playtest of the next edition of D&D, then called One D&D, and there were a lot of speculations and rumors that the OGL would either be discontinued or changed under this new edition. In a leaked OGL 1.1 draft in December of 2022, many of these fears would seem to have been confirmed. The leak included updated terms that would de-authorize the use of the OGL 1.0, which meant that every game or product that had used the OGL, new and old, would have to submit their work to WotC, because they would own any legal right to the products produced under the OGL. The revenue earned related to the OGL would also have had to be reported to WotC if it exceeded $50.000 annually, and royalties would have to be paid if it exceeded $750.000.
Mid January 2023, WotC came out with a new proposal for the OGL version 1.2. This was after a lot of backlash from the community and other producers and users of the OGL 1.0. Even the original creator of the OGL, Ryan S. Dancey, had come out and publicly talked negatively about the leaked 1.1. This 1.2 version went back on many of the bad decisions that were mentioned in the leaked 1.1, but it kept one of the most controversial and most disliked suggestions: to de-authorize the OGL. Luckily, later on in late January, WotC caved due to the feedback they got on the proposal and never went through with the changes. The OGL 1.0a still stands. What they did was to make a change and remove D&D 5e SDR from the OGL and over to a Creative Commons License, and when D&D 5.5e was released in 2024, it was also placed under a CC-License instead of the OGL.
Thanks to WotC mismanagement, greed, or whatever else you want to call it, the community got outraged. That is where Paizo stepped in. They had greatly benefitted from the OGL and had created their own TTRPG Pathfinder. They, together with Azora Law, came forward and suggested making a new open source license for TTRPGs and other creations wanting to use the elements included – what came from this was the ORC License (Open RPG Creative). This was backed by many other creators of TTRPGs and others in the community. The ORC was not to be owned by any one company and is now under the public domain registered in the Library of Congress in the US. This also means that the license cannot be revoked, changed or amended by anyone, so what it says goes, in perpetuity.
Under the ORC there are two main parts: the ORC contents, what is shared between anyone using the license, and reserved content, pieces of lore and trademark unique to the creator. There are a few things you have to do to use the ORC. The ORC contents work on an upstream system, so if someone decides to breach the license, anyone upstream can sue them to make them comply with the license. One is to credit the creator’s system you are borrowing from, include the standard legal attributions (credit the ORC) and remember to say what is reserved content. Anything released under the ORC cannot be removed by the creator or anyone else.
So now any aspiring creators of boardgames, tabletops or roleplaying games have an open license they can use to let their imagination run wild, without fear of a big company pulling the rug from underneath them and getting ownership of the content. If you want to read more in depth what is included and excluded form the ORC I recommend the ORC AxE, which contains a “brief” and simplified version of the ORC license: https://azoralaw.com/orclicense/